Our Team

John McConnell President

John has been in the insurance industry for over 20 years, working with groups and individuals across several states. John has helped numerous companies implement employee benefits packages, business continuation plans and key man policies. John is a past president of Murray Life Underwrites and a member of NAFIA.

Judy Snyder

Judy has been in insurance for 31 years. She works with employee benefit packages and also life insurance and medicare supplements for individuals. Her years of experience have benefited many companies as well as individuals. She has received her LUTCF designation.


Angela received her Master of Science from the University of Kentucky's College of Design. She decided to give up her full-time job as a designer for the State of KY, to be able to move back to her hometown of Murray, KY. Since 2010, she has worked with McConnell Insurance, as a Colonial Life coordinator and enroller. In her role as account coordinator, Angela builds databases with account-specific benefit packages for the enrollment process. As an enroller, she counsels employees on a one-to one basis about their benefit needs and enrolls them in the benefits offered by their employers.

LaCosta Hays

LaCosta joined McConnell Insurance Agency as a highly motivated Account Executive. Prepared to service accounts through an established portfolio, LaCosta prides herself through organizational skills designed to benefit each accounts specific need. A life-long resident of Calloway County, she is a graduate from Murray State University with a Bachelor of Science degree in Public Relations and a minor in Organizational Communication. With a clear knowledge of both sales and service, she is a licensed agent available for one-to-one enrollment in addition to functioning as a direct point of contact for the agency./p>

With over 15 years of professional experience in customer service and relationship building, she also serves as a member of the Rotary Club of Murray, Chamber of Commerce Board Member and Angel’s Attic Board Member.

Megan Mathis

Megan is a Calloway County native and a graduate from Murray State University with a Bachelor of Science degree in Sociology. After graduating from MSU Megan joined the Americorps and dedicated a year volunteering with foster youth in the Louisville Metro area. Megan joined the McConnell Insurance Team as an Account Specialist in 2016 and is dedicated to superb customer service. She has a great love for gardening and beekeeping and is an active volunteer with Murray’s community garden. Megan is an outdoor enthusiast and enjoys hiking, camping, and kayaking.

McConnell Insurance Agency

Our Services